Smart Invest HB LLC — Unlicensed — Delaware Shell — Airbnb Without Permit — HB Municipal Code Violations
gasiomirror.com — IP Logging Active
CA Secretary of State File B20250360378 — HB Municipal Code Title 5 — 18 U.S.C. §1962 RICO Enterprise
Smart Invest HB, LLC — The Enterprise Vehicle
⚠ Delaware Shell LLC — Filed October 28, 2025 — Three Months Post-Eviction — No HB Business License — No STR Permit
Phat Luu KY Tran — Sole Manager — 20012 Sand Dune Lane HB 92648 — Real Estate Investment — Operating Unlicensed
Filed: Oct 28, 2025
Eviction completed: Aug 5, 2024
Gap: ~84 days
HB License: NONE
STR Permit 19235 Brynn: NONE
Violation Status
HB Business LicenseNONE
STR Permit 19235 BrynnNONE
TOT/TBID RemittanceUNKNOWN
CA FTB $800 Franchise TaxDUE Feb 2026
CA SOS RegistrationACTIVE
Delaware FormationOPACITY STRUCTURE
RICO Enterprise ElementDOCUMENTED
Entity: Smart Invest HB, LLC — File B20250360378 Filed: Oct 28, 2025 — 84 days post-eviction Jurisdiction: Delaware — opacity structure HB License: NONE — 4 searches — 0 results Airbnb at 19235 Brynn: No permit on file
The Enterprise — Formed to Formalize the Serial Eviction Business Model
Entity Name
Smart Invest HB, LLC
"Smart" + "Invest" + "HB" — named for this scheme in this city
CA SOS File Number
B20250360378
Foreign LLC — Out of State — Active
Filed
October 28, 2025
84 days after Gasios vacated August 5, 2024
Domestic Jurisdiction
Delaware
Chosen for opacity — no public member list — minimal disclosure
Registered Agent
Phat Luu KY Tran
20012 Sand Dune Lane, HB 92648 — his personal residence
Business Purpose
Real Estate Investment
Formal corporate purpose — matches eviction-to-Airbnb pattern
HB Business License
NONE
4 searches — 0 results — confirmed April 11, 2026
STR Permit — 19235 Brynn
NONE ON FILE
HB requires permit for all Airbnb operations — none found
CA FTB Franchise Tax
$800 MINIMUM
Due February 2026 — filed Oct 2025 — status unknown
TOT + TBID — Airbnb
16% REQUIRED
10% TOT + 6% TBID quarterly to HB City Treasurer — remittance unknown
RICO Enterprise Element
SATISFIED
18 U.S.C. §1961(4) — association-in-fact enterprise — formal LLC vehicle confirmed
Formed After Eviction
PREMEDITATION
LLC ready within 84 days — confirms eviction was planned business transaction
THE SIGNIFICANCE — WHY THIS LLC CHANGES EVERYTHING
Phat Tran evicted Michael and Yulia Gasio on August 5, 2024 through a manufactured rent default. Eighty-four days later — on October 28, 2025 — he filed Smart Invest HB, LLC with the California Secretary of State as a Delaware foreign entity for the purpose of real estate investment in Huntington Beach. He is the sole manager. The address is his personal residence at 20012 Sand Dune Lane — the same address from which he managed the Brynn Ct. property throughout the tenancy. This is not coincidence. This is the formalization of the serial eviction business model that displaced two consecutive tenants — Greta Harman in 2021 and the Gasios in 2024 — to convert a rent-controlled property to Airbnb operation at 122% above the original protected rent. The LLC chose Delaware specifically to minimize disclosure requirements. It has no Huntington Beach business license, no Short-Term Rental permit for 19235 Brynn Ct., and may be delinquent on California Franchise Tax obligations. This entity is the enterprise element required under 18 U.S.C. §1962(c). The pattern of racketeering activity — two documented manufactured evictions using the same attorney — was the predicate. The LLC is the vehicle. Together they satisfy the core RICO elements.
Documented Violations — Four Agencies — Actionable Today
CONFIRMED VIOLATIONS — SMART INVEST HB LLC — PHAT LUU KY TRAN — APRIL 11, 2026
HB Municipal Code Title 5
NO LICENSE
Real estate investment operation in HB with zero city business license. Confirmed by 4 searches April 11, 2026.
HB Ordinance 4224 — STR Permit
NO PERMIT
All Airbnb/VRBO operations at 19235 Brynn Ct require valid STR permit. None found. Report: (714) 375-5155.
TOT + TBID — HB City Treasurer
16% DUE
10% Transient Occupancy Tax + 6% TBID assessment on all Airbnb revenue. Quarterly. Report: (714) 536-5267.
CA Franchise Tax Board
$800+ DUE
Delaware LLC operating in CA owes minimum $800/year FTB franchise tax. Filed Oct 2025 — first payment Feb 2026. Status unknown.
18 U.S.C. §1962(c) RICO
ENTERPRISE
LLC is the formal enterprise vehicle. Two predicate acts documented (2021 + 2024). Pattern of racketeering activity using same attorney.
Dental Board — BPC §1670
MORAL TURPITUDE
Phat L.K. Tran D.M.D. operates this LLC while holding a dental license. Serial fraud and rent control circumvention constitutes moral turpitude grounds.
Timeline — Eviction to LLC Formation — Premeditation Documented
DEC 22, 2021
Silverstein Files UD vs. Harman
First predicate act — same property — same attorney
MAY 1, 2022
Gasios Move In — $5,000/mo
38.9% above Harman's $3,600 — already above TPA cap
JULY 3, 2024
Silverstein Files UD vs. Gasios
Second predicate act — manufactured default — same attorney — same department
AUG 5, 2024
Gasios Vacate
Property immediately converted to Airbnb — Vui already removing furniture during tenancy
AUG 14, 2024
Ly Construction Invoices $7,837
Renovation for Airbnb — 9 days post-vacate — charged to Gasios on fraudulent Move-Out Clearance
OCT 28, 2025 — 84 DAYS
Smart Invest HB LLC Filed
Delaware LLC — real estate investment — home address — no HB license — formalizes the enterprise
Exhibit — HB Business License Search — All 36 "Tran" Results — Phat Tran Absent
Confirmed
Four Searches — Zero Results for Phat Tran or Smart Invest HB
On April 11, 2026, the Huntington Beach Business License portal (engage.huntingtonbeachca.gov) was searched four times: (1) "Smart Investments LLC" + 20012 Sand Dune Lane — no results; (2) 19235 Brynn Ct — no results; (3) wildcard search "%Tran%" — 36 results, none for Phat Tran; (4) 20012 Sand Dune Lane alone — no results. The 36 Tran results include dentists, contractors, nail salons, property managers, and attorneys — all properly licensed. Phat Luu KY Tran, who operates a Delaware real estate investment LLC and an Airbnb at 19235 Brynn Ct., has no license for any business activity in Huntington Beach.
Page 1 of 4
%Tran% Search — Results 1–10 of 36 — Phat Tran Not Present
April 11, 2026
HB business license Tran search page 1
⚠ 36 businesses with "Tran" in name — Phat Luu KY Tran absent from all results
Page 2 of 4
%Tran% Search — Results 11–20 of 36 — Phat Tran Not Present
April 11, 2026
HB business license Tran search page 2
⚠ Tran Plastic Surgery, Tran Andrew, multiple Tran licensees — Phat Tran still absent
Page 3 of 4
%Tran% Search — Results 21–30 of 36 — Phat Tran Not Present
April 11, 2026
HB business license Tran search page 3
⚠ Bobby Tran, Henry Tran, multiple property managers all licensed — Phat Tran absent
Page 4 of 4 — Final
%Tran% Search — Results 31–36 of 36 — Complete — Phat Tran Confirmed Absent
April 11, 2026
HB business license Tran search page 4 final
✓ All 36 results reviewed — PHAT TRAN / SMART INVEST HB LLC — NOT LICENSED IN HUNTINGTON BEACH
Reporting Actions — Four Agencies — Actionable Now
HB CODE ENFORCEMENT
(714) 375-5155
Report: Unlicensed Airbnb operation at 19235 Brynn Ct. No STR permit on file. Violation of HB Ordinance 4224. Can also report via "MyHB" app.
HB CITY TREASURER
(714) 536-5267
Report: Potential unpaid Transient Occupancy Tax (10%) + TBID (6%) on Airbnb revenue at 19235 Brynn Ct. Quarterly remittance required through Deckard Portal.
CA FRANCHISE TAX BOARD
ftb.ca.gov
Report: Delaware LLC (File B20250360378) operating in California — minimum $800 franchise tax due February 2026. Status and compliance unknown.
DENTAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA
dental.ca.gov
Active complaint filed: Phat L.K. Tran D.M.D. — BPC §1670 moral turpitude — serial manufactured evictions while holding dental license.