The Financial Motive — Why They Evicted a 72-Year-Old Disabled Tenant
Gasio Rent-Controlled Tenancy
$5,350
Per month · AB 1482 protected · 27 consecutive early payments
→
Airbnb Conversion — Host "Vui"
$7,786
Per month · Unlawful STR · HB Municipal Code §230.15 violation
Monthly Profit From Eviction
+$2,436/mo
55% increase over rent-controlled rate. This is the documented financial motive for fraudulently evicting a protected-class elder tenant.Annual Code Enforcement Liability
$180,000+
HB Municipal Code §230.15 — unhosted vacation rentals expressly prohibited. $1,000/day fine. Code Enforcement notified July 3, 2025.Carpet Fraud
$7,835
LY Construction invoice: "carpet replacement — dog pee bad smell." Move-out photos show clean carpet. Airbnb listing shows vinyl plank flooring — no carpet exists. The charge funded the Airbnb remodel.Total Fabricated Damage Invoice
$20,980
From LY Construction — Anna Ly's family entity. Pre-dated. Transmitted from Tran's dental office. Baseboard line item confirms full remodel, not damage repair.The Airbnb Operator — Vui Nguyen
Vui Nguyen — Airbnb Host
Identity verified on Airbnb. Lives in Corona, CA. Speaks English and Vietnamese. Seven-year host managing multiple Huntington Beach properties.
Listed 19235 Brynn Ct as "Entire home in Huntington Beach" — 7 guests, 3 bedrooms, 5 beds, 2.5 baths. Self check-in with keypad. Listing appeared within weeks of Gasio eviction.
Took Michael's bunk bed frame from the property in June 2024 while the lease was still active — conversion of personal property during active tenancy. Establishes Vui was operating at the property before the eviction was final.
789 REVIEWS
4.77★ RATING
7 YEARS HOSTING
CORONA, CA
Exhibits — Screenshots & Communications
Exhibit AIR-A — Airbnb Listing · 19235 Brynn Ct · "Live the beach life" · Hosted by Vui
The Airbnb listing at 19235 Brynn Ct — the Gasio family's former home. Interior photos show vinyl plank flooring throughout (billed to Gasios as "carpet replacement"), staged furniture, remodeled kitchen. Listed at $7,786/month. "Entire home in Huntington Beach, California" — 7 guests, 3 bedrooms, 5 beds, 2.5 baths. Hosted by Vui, 7 years hosting, 2 reviews at time of capture. Unhosted vacation rental in violation of HB Municipal Code §230.15 (banned since 2022).
Exhibit AIR-B — Notice to Vui via Airbnb · July 3, 2025
Formal notice sent to Vui Nguyen via Airbnb messaging platform on July 3, 2025. Subject: "NOTICE OF VIOLATION OF MUNICIPAL, STATE, AND FEDERAL LAW." Cites HB Municipal Code §230.15, B&P §10176(a)/§10177(d), and 18 USC §1343 wire fraud. Notifies Vui she has knowingly aided Dr. Phat Tran in violating HB's 2022 ordinance banning unhosted short-term rentals. States Code Enforcement has been notified and a formal complaint filed.
Exhibit AIR-C — Demand for Return of Stolen Property · Read by Vui
Demand for return of stolen property sent via Airbnb messaging. "Read by Vui" — confirmed delivery and read receipt. Demands immediate return of the daybed frame taken from the property during active tenancy in June 2024. States Vui took possession of clearly marked personal property belonging to the Gasio family. "Your license is on the line. So is your reputation. Know that the law sees what you've done, and God sees even more." Filed with HBPD, California DRE, IRS, FBI.
Documented Violations — Municipal, State, and Federal
HB MUNICIPAL CODE §230.15 — SHORT-TERM RENTALS PROHIBITED
Unhosted Vacation Rental in Residential Zone — $1,000/Day Fine
Huntington Beach expressly prohibits unhosted vacation rentals since the 2022 ordinance. Enforcement carries a $1,000/day fine. Code Enforcement was notified on July 3, 2025. The listing operated from at least November 2024 (booking dates visible in listing). At $1,000/day, the accumulated fine exposure through 2025 alone exceeds $180,000. Both Dr. Tran (owner) and Vui Nguyen (operator) are financially liable for each day the listing remains online or rented.
CALIFORNIA B&P §10176(a), §10177(d) — LICENSED AGENT FRAUD
Fraud, Misrepresentation, and Negligence by Licensed Real Estate Professional
As a licensee, Vui has a fiduciary duty to act honestly, verify legal use, and protect the public. Aiding an unlawful rental subjects her to disciplinary action and license revocation by the California DRE. Her behavior constitutes "willful disregard for the law." She is operating a commercial rental enterprise through a platform that uses interstate communications — establishing federal wire fraud jurisdiction.
18 USC §1343 — FEDERAL WIRE FRAUD
Each Airbnb Booking Is a Separate Wire Fraud Count
Use of interstate wires — the Airbnb platform, text messages, email — to further a scheme to defraud. Every booking processed through Airbnb constitutes a separate wire fraud event. With 789 reviews across Vui's hosting career and multiple Huntington Beach properties, the scale of wire fraud exposure is substantial. Each count carries up to 5 years federal imprisonment on first offense, escalating to 20+ years on subsequent counts.
CALIFORNIA PENAL CODE §496 — CONVERSION OF PERSONAL PROPERTY
Bunk Bed Frame Taken During Active Tenancy — June 2024
Vui Nguyen took possession of Michael Gasio's clearly marked daybed/bunk bed frame from 19235 Brynn Ct in June 2024 — while the lease was still active. Rather than placing it in the garage as the shipper instructed, she took it for personal use. Demand for return was sent via Airbnb — "Read by Vui" — and ignored. This establishes: (1) conversion of personal property, (2) Vui was operating at the property before eviction was final, and (3) the Airbnb conversion was underway during the Gasio tenancy.
42 USC §3604, §3617 — FAIR HOUSING ACT VIOLATIONS
HUD OIG Complaint Filed April 2, 2026 — Fraudulent Airbnb Conversion
Formal complaint submitted to HUD Office of Inspector General documenting the fraudulent conversion of rent-controlled residential housing occupied by a 72-year-old disabled tenant to an unlicensed short-term Airbnb rental. HUD OIG is actively pursuing this pattern nationally — the displacement of protected-class tenants from rent-controlled housing for Airbnb profit. The Gasio eviction is a textbook case of the conversion pattern HUD has identified as a national enforcement priority. Complaint requests Fair Housing investigation, pattern-and-practice investigation, and referral to HUD FHEO.
The Carpet Fraud — $7,835 for Carpet That Doesn't Exist
Smoking Gun — BPC §17500 False Advertising
LY Construction invoiced $7,835 for "carpet replacement — dog pee bad smell." The move-out photographs show clean, undamaged carpet. The Airbnb listing shows vinyl plank flooring throughout — no carpet exists anywhere in the property. The carpet was never replaced. The $7,835 charge funded the vinyl flooring installation for the Airbnb conversion. The outgoing protected-class tenant's security deposit paid for it. Three or more fake photos were used in the Homes.com listing advertising "new carpet" — when no new carpet was ever installed. This is provable false advertising under BPC §17500 and establishes the damage invoice as a fraudulent instrument used to fund a commercial conversion billed to the victim.
Code Enforcement Notification — July 3, 2025
Email to HB Code Enforcement — CC'd to Lt. Randall, FBI LA, DOJ Criminal Fraud
On July 3, 2025, formal notification was emailed to code.enforcement@surfcity-hb.org and to Dr. Phat Tran (kyphat@yahoo.com), with CC to Lt. Shawn Randall (HBPD), FBI Los Angeles (losangeles@fbi.gov), and DOJ Criminal Fraud Division (criminal.fraud@usdoj.gov). The email forwarded the complete Airbnb violation notice sent to Vui, the listing screenshots, the property address confirmation, and the federal wire fraud statute poster. This establishes that Huntington Beach Code Enforcement, HBPD, the FBI, and the DOJ were all placed on notice of the unlawful Airbnb operation on the same day — July 3, 2025.
Multi-Agency Filing Record — Airbnb Fraud Component
HUD OIG
Filed April 2, 2026. Fair Housing Act violations — 42 USC §3604, §3617. Fraudulent conversion of rent-controlled housing to unlawful Airbnb. Pattern and practice investigation requested. Referral to HUD FHEO for formal administrative complaint.
HB Code Enforcement
Notified July 3, 2025. Municipal Code §230.15 — unhosted STR prohibited. $1,000/day fine. Formal complaint filed naming Dr. Tran and Vui Nguyen.
FBI Los Angeles
CC'd July 3, 2025. 18 USC §1343 wire fraud — each Airbnb booking is a separate count. Interstate communications used to further scheme to defraud.
California DRE
Active complaints. Vui's participation in unlawful rental operation subjects her to disciplinary action. B&P §10176(a), §10177(d) — fraud, misrepresentation, negligence.